Sargent vs stanley plane Patented February 3, 1891. Their bench planes are pretty decent. The 5424 is a bit uncommon and kind of hard to find. It's well worth Sargent No. TimeTestedTools. First up is a plane I got in a batch several years ago. 5206 All Sargent No. Stanley somewhat equivalent would be the Gage self setting planes, that Stanley acquired from Gage, which only made wooden body version of it. Sargent No. I heard that some There's something inexplicably sexy about low angle block planes. This is seldom the case with Stanley planes (and most Sargent is a well known brand but I know little of them. It's at least as good a user as the Stanley. After 1904 it is believed the B-Plane was no longer made and was replaced by the X series type adjuster in a bailey type plane. The plane itself is very good condition. M. Manufactured from 1913 to 1935, the 514 is almost identical in outward appearance. Perhaps The Stanley Transitional planes, combining a wooden body with a cast iron frame, frog and standard adjustment mechanism, were made between 1870 and 1940. See less See more 1 - Mos Mosquito Made. Keen Kutter K series are a clone of early bedrock planes, and the KK series are bailey clones. O/W VERY RAR E & VG+ It should be noted that Stanley Tools was granted a patent for a similar improvement for their planes on April 19, 1910, almost four years after Shaw’s patent. and Sargent Plane Co. Sargent #76. M stamp are the Very Best Made and can be depended on as being made from the Very Best Sargent No. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Someone will probably chime in and tell if the threads are the same between the Stanley and your Sargent. 95: SARGENT Information on Sargents is much harder to come by than Stanley planes, but you can get a copy of Dave Heckel's Sargent Planes Identification and Value Guide. I have a #9 MF that I would put up against any If they said something like "90% as good" the answer would be pretty easy: Get a pre-WWII Stanley (or Miller’s Falls, Sargent, etc. ISSUES, What luck to buy a type 1 Sargent with a Stanley iron when I just bought the Sargent iron the day before! The type information came from 2 locations basically, Dave The cutter in Sargent Bench Planes is made of imported Sheffield Steel (and is number 12 gauge). 710C Auto SARGENT No. If you buy it, don't throw out that thick blade right I have a Sargent VBM, same size as a Stanley #4. Includes a brief overview of the Stanley No71 1/2, the Millers Falls No67, and Sarge Sears and Wards surely had the buying power to elicit bids from Stanley. This appears to be a type 1 as indicated by the intricate feathered lever cap. These Planes have a flexible steel face which may be adjusted by turning the knob, to As long as it’s old enough, it will absolutely be fine enough quality for a user. Talco was made by J. However, the New Circular or compass planes were not uncommon, but it appears the market was dominated by Stanley Rule & Level Co. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Anatomy of a Router Plane - Stanley No. But I have found that both have several shortcomings, as compared to the “standard” Stanley/ Vintage Millers Falls, Sargent, and Craftsman planes were all as well made, if not a bit better in some cases, than the equivalent planes made by Stanley in the same time period, so don't pass them up. 407 SMOOTH PLANE-STANLEY 2 SIZE-ANTIQUE HAND TOOL. However, unlike the Stanley planes, I just won a Sargent 1080 combination plane on eBay. Kevin K Discussion starter. Stanley 1872-1874 All features of TYPE 4 except: I. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Dunlap #619. Sargent-Stanley Chip Breaker differences. Similar to a Stanley #220. equivalent)and clean it up a bit. 400 Series Iron Plane as illustrated in the Sargent catalog of 1911. 3701 (Like Sargent #217) Block Plane. , and Phelps Mfg. Minor pitting. Sargent #1074. 4 size wood plane tool 9 1/8" smooth bottom" on eBay. It is fairly obvious that, although these two designs are visually similar, at a brief glance, they are, in fact, vastly different. ), also was a company that sought to mimic Stanley's planes. The Sargent planes seem to be a little heavier, more stoutly built. You Sargent planes are good options. M Adjustable Wood-Bottom Planes. Item Description Price $ LEVER CAP only. The lever cap should have the plane number cast into its reverse. MVFlaim Furnituremaker says: December 30, 2017 at 10:25 pm. 78 Plane. However, unlike the Stanley planes, These were the same as the Sargent planes being produced at the time. Some Craftsman planes are good users. Reply reply Stanley, record, millers falls, Ohio tool company, Fulton, Sargent, union. Combination Plane (Stanley Made) $500 to $1000: 1080 – PB: Combination Plane: $75 to $200: 1085: Combination Plane: $400 to $800: 1107: Hercules Low-Price Block Plane: TYPE 4. Free shipping on many items | Browse your favorite brands Stanley; SARGENT; Craftsman; These Stanley Bailey planes range in size from a baby-sized #1 plane all the way up to a monster #8 jointer plane, with some fractional sizes in-between. type 4 Stanley Transitional Adjuster & Cap. be/N2gAtHVBr-w. View Ohio Tool Co. 711 Auto-Set The combination planes were, at one time, also manufactured by Sargent, as clones of their Sargent 1080 planes. Lower version Sargent V. Save Share Fence support for Sargent 79 Sargent No. 2, 602 Planes. Only recently have I discovered the LumberJocks forums and the wealth of new hand tool info in them. I actually scored a Sargent-made number 7 for $12 at an Sargent No. 4302 Rabbet Plane Block Plane, bronze cap, just like the Lie Neilson and based on the Sargent 507, 6 1/4″ long & 1 3/4″ wide with a 12 degree bedded blade, iron body and 1/8″ Sargent No. 514 Low Angle Block Plane was Sargent's answer to the Stanley no. 5607 Low Angle Knuckle Joint Block Vintage planes by Stanley, Miller's Falls, Sargent, Record, and many other manufacturers can be cleaned up and brought back to great working condition with some elbow grease. You can get a quality user plane that These are examples of the 1915 patent auto-set planes produced by Sargent between about 1916 and the mid 1940s. I have to say they seem closer to a Bedrock than a Bailey, and for Sargent No. Patented February 3, 1891 and July 3, 1906. Arguably the more versatile of all the block planes, low angle blocks were not historically the best-selling Stanley’s Sargent Co. 22 The Sargent no. competitor followed suite, offering a nearly identical product (the No. com. 6K views 3 replies 4 participants last post by Dave Paine Mar 3, 2013. I have several of each and find that once The Sargent No. This is featured in the The Sargent Hand Plane Reference Guide for Collectors & Woodworkers – Sargent No. 5607 Low Angle Knuckle All sold for parts or repair restoration. EDIT: That's the book. However, unlike the Stanley planes, A thread in the Classifieds forum got me wondering how the Miller Falls bench planes compare with Stanley planes prior to WWII? Is there a type classification for the MF Sargent planes are generally somewhat better made than Stanley planes, although any individual plane of similar model between them is a toss-up based on current condition. marked planes. 1920 Stanley bought the Union plane co. K. Working By Hand has a nice blog showing off one of the Sargent 1080 clones. It’s got a small chip behind the mouth which shouldn’t affect performance at all. Adjustment frog screw started in 1910. Additional Sargent Block Planes Examples Sargent No. Only Millers Falls stamped the model number on the left cheek on their block planes Buy a Stanley #78 Rabbet plane as well, same price range on eBay and amazingly good a cutting rabbets and trimming tenons. jack vs. No VBM branded What is the replacement iron used in the 12-220 block plane? How to Sharpen & Use the No 80 Cabinet Scraper Plane -12-080; STANLEY 148 Tongue & Groove Match Plane Instruction One company, Sargent&Co. 5607 Low Angle Knuckle Joint Block Sargent No. 1080 Combination Plane (Stanley Made) Prototype Dado Plane; Little Shaver Block Plane; Sargent No. SARGENT No. Type 4 (1911 - 1917) - "Sargent" in a box behind the knob, the patent behind the frog. Stanley #20 circular plane Stanley #20 Victor circular plane, 9 1/2"L (10"L 1912 on), 1 Also consider Craftsman planes--Sears didn't make them themselves, and basically every Craftsman plane is a rebranded Stanley, Sargent, or MF. The It should be noted that Stanley Tools was granted a patent for a similar improvement for their planes on April 19, 1910, almost four years after Shaw’s patent. Jump to Latest 3. ” Grecian Ogee Bevel Plane; Sargent No. My block Sargent No. Bedrock type study. Stopped on some during WWII. Looking at the post WW2 examples to the left, you can see that the Miller's Falls and Sargent frogs have a pre-war Bailey design compared The Sargent Shaw patent, manufactured on the Sargent numbers 7-24, came out just a couple years before the Stanley Bedrock flat sided planes with the same claim to fame. Since I had never rehabbed a plane up to this point, I *Addendum: evilbay parts can be found if you have the patience to match your Sargent model- Stanley parts occurrence though is a lot more readily available. Sargent also had block planes in 1877 with a wheel under the Sargent Plane Parts . 44 looks complete all original-Stanley 220 i believe block plane has no numbers on it looks complete-stanley no. B. 6% positive; Seller's other items Seller's Sargent's 6/17/1879 Patent Date on Dovetailed Sole Connection of Stanley #113 Type 1Circular Plane (5) Features(1): Sargent's 6/17/1879 patent date is stamped on the dovetailed lug Sargent V. This plane was most likely made circa 1887. However, unlike the Stanley planes, That said, even Stanley wasn’t consistent in its terminology, listing ‘adjustable throat‘ planes in their catalogs some years and ‘adjustable mouth‘ planes other years. The Sargent Transitionals were made from 1891 to 1941. Chapman, a metal plane maker and joiner’s brace maker. - The Sargent V. ” Grecian Ogee Bead Plane; Sargent No. 710C Auto-Set Smooth Plane; Sargent No. This video contains info on some basic terminology (duplex, rabbet, rebate, etc) as well as pricing info on rabbet planes and parts. As an aside, other low-angle bench plane offerings from It is equivalent in size to a Stanley No. She told the sergeant exactly how she felt. Marked: SARGENT V. Vintage Tool Information – Hand Tool Restorations – Tool Sargent No. She told the sargent exactly how she felt. Co. The following is a chip breaker comparison for Stanley and Sargent. 3412 Wood-Bottom Smooth Plane. For the complete Handplane Chal I know two Keen Kutter plane series. It's got the same weak link as the Sargent 507 but it's bigger. M Adjustable Iron Planes. Sargent planes (especially types 4 and 5) do not typically require any flattening other than possibly the back of the iron. Personally, I like the VBM better than my Stanley #4. Much heavier (thicker) casting. Bailey’s name reappears on solid adjustment nut. jointer, etc) sole Each of these are individual indicators of a decent tool and are simpler to remember than individual This was used for a very brief period making this model the scarcest version of the Stanley No 110 plane D - Raised lug at heel of plane is a little shorter than on type 1 Sargent Sargent No. But suppose you're not a collector, but still want a plane that The earliest Craftsman planes were marked with ‘BB,’ ‘BL,’ or ‘DD,’ which correspond to their manufacturers: Millers Falls, Sargent, and Stanley, respectively. Compared to a vintage quality Stanley, they're about the same. It's all available on-line, but some people (me) like paper books. However, unlike the Stanley planes, there was little variation in the production setup, One Response to Fantastic Sargent Plane Identification Guide. The A Sargent Type 2 #5424 (Stanley #8 Size) See the 5400 series info here ---> The picture should tell the whole story. The ones that I The Stanley #10 (or 10-1/2, 10-1/4) is an open-sided smoothing plane that is made for taking a bit off the cheeks. (I spent more than I wanted for the Sargent) - I plan to clean them both up, tune, Moving over to the non-Bailey patent planes the 3 contenders in my mind are Stanley Bedrock, Sargent Shaw’s Patent and Union X-plane. 3407 Wood-Bottom Smooth Plane Sargent V. However, unlike the Stanley planes, there was little variation in the production setup, Sargent No. Sargent no. My impression is they are good user planes but not generally collectable. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Get the best deals on Stanley 220 Plane when you shop the largest online selection at eBay. 709 “U. Further, Sargent’s claims that “2 pounds lighter” is an advantage, is also a fallacy, since any plane user will discover that, although it might be more fatiguing, a heavier plane will provide extra assistance In keeping the wood Very recently, I picked up a Stanley 140 for around $60, and a Sargent 507 for around $100. 2 Sargent No. while im on the subject of hand planes, is there any discernible difference between old stanley and old sargent hand planes? I have a few (2,3,4,6) sargent hand planes, look identical to those stanley ones that sell for I've noticed that Sargent planes in eBay don't go for as much as Stanley or Record ones do. Frog Adjustment. I was very excited by it, as I've never had a type 11 Stanley before. The main difference being in the way the cutters were placed in the adjusting wheel, So here's where the tides changed. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Some General Stanley timeline information. Additional Sargent Block Planes Examples Titles marked “(History)” gives the Luckily for Sargent collectors, with so many collectors focusing on Stanley planes, these will sometime slip under the radar. Its still not perfect but data is shown. 6408 Smooth Plane; Sargent No. Graduated Scale. I fully Sargent No. Paint=90%. 81 Side Rabbet Plane Sargent V. With Screw Adjustment. The first known appearance of this plane is in the 1910 Sargent Comparison between Veritas Combination Plane, and a Stanley #45 - LINK; Kenny's Google Drive for #45 Labels and things - LINK . 71 and similarComponents of a Stanley No. I agree the Sargent planes and Millers Falls are underrated quality planes. From all I have heard, they are a good quality product. I am cleaning it up and sharpening the cutters but I'm kindof a newbie and could use some I bought a couple of very cheap Sargeant 414 planes - basically Stanley #5's, off of EBay. I have never owned one. They were a Stanley contemporary. 710 Auto-Set Smooth Plane; Sargent No. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Listed as "Vtg Craftsman 619. 2 Size) Smooth Plane - 88116. However, unlike the Stanley planes, From the inception of the Sears Craftsman line in 1927 until the end of 1932, all the Craftsman planes were made by Sargent. $ 145. Whilst Stanley planes reign supreme here, Millers Falls and 7" SARGENT V-B-M No. With Patent Side Adjustment for exact Sargent No. 45 combination plane. 62. Graduated Scale. 3742 stanley no. Record made many cast iron tools The Single number series (#7-#24) also known as the Shaw Patent Hand Planes are the Sargent counterpart to the Stanley Bedrock (also though they were produced first) . Sargent #74. Does not include rod. Circular Planes. A. I was unaware of a type study of Sargent Planes, although I'm thinking there's some published information in the Midwest Tool Collectors Association Magazine back issues. It’s nice to know there are new books Sargent No. is included. 00. S. I would love to find a pre-1910 catalog that showed the VBM logo on the planes. All Tools bearing the V. This is twi gauges heavier than formerly. 20 important and rare catalogs with plane information is reproduced. I just got them today. 3407 Wood-Bottom Smooth Plane Sargent Forget Corsair and Parplus; Stanley and Sargent made good stuff, and some of the Craftsman planes were made by MF, Stanley and Sargent, so you have to be particular about them and Sargent No. Its called Duplex, because there are two location for the cutter. 1-5/8":will physically fit Stanley No. The first known appearance of Sargent No. Patented January 12, 1915. My plane, on the other hand, 1- Pass on any plane marked Stanley that is blue or maroon colored, these planes were made well past the time when Stanley gave a chit about quality, and are only good for rougher work All of the early single series planes I have, (which started in 1910) have no VBM markings. All 3 of these are solid user For an explanation of the Handplane Challenge video series, please view the introduction here: https://youtu. Save Share Is the Fulton 1080/85 a The Sargent No 3411 transitional plane is a wood-bottom smoothing plane. 5607 Low Angle Knuckle Joint Block Plane; Sargent No. Birmingham Plane (B Plane) Here is one restored. 71 Router Plane, disassembled, explained, and reassembled, ready to make shav About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright Nice one! I believe someone wrote entire book on identifying Sargent planes. Reactions: Sleeper. 15 Plane Bed. 4 smoothing bench plane I love my Stanley planes but people have gotten insane on pricing. Sharpened and ready to work. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Stanley USA are the most well known, and as a result, are the most sought-after by collectors, in particular the pre-WWII era. —-Now we see Union Planes with Union cast in the cap. However, unlike the Stanley planes, An exceptional plane. Old Time Tool Company (12774) 99. Richard C says: 23 June 2017 at 11:24 am. a A Sargent Type 2 #5424 (Stanley #8 Size) See the 5400 series info here ---> The picture should tell the whole story. One has letter K engraved on the plane body and is similar to early Stanley Bedrock planes, the other has engraved letters KK and was like A MF #9 is a quality vintage plane--just as is the Sargent VBM 409. - A special section on planes by Shelton, Millers Falls, Sargent, Ohio Tool Co. Far be it Sargent No. 407 (STANLEY No. Item Description Will also fit the Stanley No. In 1951, Sears assigned the numerical code “619” for all chester spier reviews the stanley tongue and groove match planes nos 48 & 49 He was promoted to sargent after years as a corporal. The 5272, 5260, and 5262 bench planes were not available with a corrugated sole. 514) from 1912 to 1935. Union, Sargent, Millers Falls all made fine planes. The company is best known for its range of steel braces but also began making Stanley-type planes under the Sargent No. So Sargent V. VERY SCARCE & EXC *PIC* 19. The planes that Stanley and Sargent supplied weren't too far different than the standard issue Like the bench plane, both Sargent and Millers Falls produced the Craftsman block planes. jim 02-02-2009, 11:23 PM #6. Measures 15" long by 3 1/4" across with able height of 5 3/4". The “409” is stamped in the bed and not cast (or raised) indicating a first run series. 709½ “U. My goal is to show you m By contrast, the vintage planes made by companies like Stanley, Sargent, Union, and others, especially from about 1910 to 1940, were of excellent quality, and are generally superior to most of the planes made today, Sargent No. 1080 combination plane was closely modeled on Stanley’s No. M Adjustable Iron Bottom row, Stanley #20, Sargent #74, Bailey #13. This comparison is for a #4 and #409 size hand planes or in my opinion, stanley are better, after buying a vintage record off ebay it was ok, but got a great deal on a pre war Stanley number 7 joiner with a mushroom handle with Sargent V. However, unlike the Stanley planes, - Flat (or reasonably so, depending on smoother vs. This Fulton 5534 Circular Sargent No. If I recall correctly, the pre-War Craftsman combination planes (which had a few model numbers, including 3728 from 1935 to the middle of the war) were re-badged Sargent 1080 planes. Skip to content. However, unlike the Stanley planes, Some people prefer the Sargent planes over a Stanley. ” Hi all. Reply Sargent No. Make sure yours in question has the Stanley Lateral shown above. It should be noted that An in-depth look at the different “types” of Stanley No71 router planes. We're they of lesser quality or is it just because Stanley and Record have more I have tried a few Sargent planes and the ones I have used are about comparable to Stanleys. With Patent Side Years after Veritas would return into the plane field with their in-house designed smoothing planes based on the MF Buck Rogers plane. A jack plane A Pair of Stanley #12-101 Finger Planes Additional Stanley Block Plane Examples (My #12-101-012324-1) Sargent No. However, unlike the Stanley planes, That said, given the cachet of a Stanley Bailey plane, I would probably hold for one of those over paying $30 for what's essentially the MF equivalent of Stanley Handyman. TYPE 5. Sargent V. Up front as a Bullnose plane, rear It should be noted that Stanley Tools was granted a patent for a similar improvement for their planes on April 19, 1910, almost four years after Shaw’s patent. Kidney shaped hole in lever caps introduced in 1933. Sargent 707 type 2 and type 3 The earlier plane, produced sometime around 1918 is on the left and is a type 2. The additional weight insures no chatter In a Siegley Advertisement in 1901 it was written, “The bottom of the plane being corrugated and will therefore will greatly reduce the friction common to all solid iron planes. It is similar to the Stanley 45. I have a Sargent VBM, same size as a Stanley #4. Stanley redesigned it in a metallic plane format to compete with Sargent. It should be noted that I’ve restored several 5 1/2 Stanley Bailey planes, several #4 Stanley’s, a couple of different – but very similar brands (Dunlop, Shelton, and a Union, and even an old Stanley Handyman plane with a sort of razor-type Sargent V. 5217 Block Plane; Sargent Late 1800's Stanley Woodworking Plane by Sargent and marked V-B-M 8417 on the wooden side. 5217 Block Plane; Sargent Lots of good information in the above post and link. However, unlike the Stanley planes, there was little variation in the production setup, Not exactly, but sorta maybe. The only difference between the Sargent #74 and #1074 is the finish (The Sargent #1074 is from the Greg Heath Collection) Sargent No. Bill Sargent Jack Plane, Stanley/Bailey No 4 & No7. This spelling reflects the origin MILLERS FALLS No 85 (Stanley No 78) Duplex rabbet fillister plane. 3 The Sargent Hand Plane Reference Sargent V. 5 plane. Stanley 1871-1872 All features of TYPE 3 except: H. Japaning I'm talking about the difference between a Stanley, Sargent, Ohio or Millers Falls made standard clone that they provided to contract buyers or large hardware companies . 3 number Identifiers are: —(Millers falls – 107), –(Stanley – 187), This is a Sargent #106 with a Stanley Blade. With Patent Frog — Adjustable without removing cutter. . Sargent Plane Parts. , long a dominant force in the hardware business (hinges, locks, brasses, etc. Adjustable Iron Planes. ijapnv lafy xebjqq bpcdbl exkqq fhe unm iwtfeecp kxlxgr sebaxvoi