Carbon vs purigen By Amy, June 11, 2014 in General Discussion. Either seems a fine approach to lowering yellowing of the water and export of organics. Seachem Purigen is a resin based on a synthetic polymer, but they don't provide specifics as to what polymer is being used Mar 3, 2013 · Purigen vs activated carbon. Oct 4, 2023 · Purigen. May 7, 2022 · Let’s take a look at Seachem Purigen vs carbon. Apr 4, 2020 · Purigen is chemical filtration, removing the same organics and other materials that lead to nitrates. Mar 14, 2021 · Both the purigen and carbon are helpful to every fishkeeper. One bonus to purigen. Carbon will remove a wide range of material from water. 720 Joined 18 yr Jan 19, 2013 · Why don't you just get some media bags and use 2 different media (like carbon and purigen) in smaller amounts so they fit into your available space. By removing organic wastes from the tank water, Seachem Purigen will keep the ammonia, nitrite and nitrate levels in check. . Oct 28, 2017 · Carbon does a better job of removing medication from the aquarium. Mar 9, 2007 · It does not effect trace minerals and is not as aggressive as some types of media. Messages 444. Amy. Absorbs a broad range of contaminants from the water, works as a gentle alternative to carbon. Since the Purigen Any suggestions on which is "better"? Maybe just use both? I'm thinking perhaps separate the two in one tray of my canister by filter floss. May 1, 2007 · purigen vs carbon. Can be recharged with bleach. Reducing organic waste will tend to Jul 3, 2010 · Purigen is one of the best water scrubbing products that I have used. So what about activated carbon? Activated carbon is a highly porous substance that works on adsorption. Mar 3, 2013 #1 I would like to know the pros and cons of purigen and activated carbon. Purigen and Matrix Carbon are both good Jun 11, 2014 · Purigen vs carbon Purigen vs carbon. However, it won’t take more than 24 hours to show its magic. In comparing the effectiveness between purigen vs carbon, carbon will effectively block water filters, especially in filtering out all contaminants. I wouldn't try to chemically reduce silicate in the tank, but folks have done it. jft Well-Known Member View Jun 18, 2017 · Prepare a solution with 4 teaspoons of dechlorinator (I use Seachem Prime for this) in a cup of water. Is Purigen better than Activated carbon? While purigen doesn’t directly replace activated carbon, it does everything activated carbon can do but much quicker. Better Value. I've read very positive reviews of Seachem's product Purigen. Jan 29, 2008 · They do. I actually prefer to use separate products versus a blended product like ChemiPure or Clear Fx Pro. Neither in my opinion can be exchanged for the other. They work in different ways. The main difference between carbon and every other chemical filtration media is carbon gets spent much faster and once spent can release bad stuff back into the water Chemipure: Purigen: Chemipure performs various cleaning functions and is considered an all-in-one filter medium. But you probaby could reduce it in the tap water where tyou do nto care about phosphate. Just because Purigen comes in a 100ml bag doesn't mean you can have to use it all at once. Jan 18, 2018 · Carbon vs. Many aquarists have reported that they did not have any negative effects after keeping them both in the fish tank. Carbon will end it life once it's being used up. Thread starter jft; Start date Dec 7, 2022; Tagged users None Jump to Last Dec 7, 2022 #1 J. In terms of pricing, Seachem Matrix provides a much better value when compared to Seachem Purigen. HyperSorb™ Absorbs organic molecules from the water, does not remove other types of contaminants. Soak Purigen in this solution for at least 8 hours. Neither is necessary for a healthy tank. Yet, we want the best product to utilize in our aquarium. Purigen might be cheaper because it can be regenerated, but depending on the quality of your local water, you might need a stronger filtering product. Activated Carbon The durability of this filter depends on the organic load inside the aquarium you use it in, which means its life expectancy can range from 10 days to over a month in accordance. I chose GAC (ROX 0. Feb 7, 2021 · Purigen vs chemipure vs carbon Vs Polyfilter. fengshui Active Member. You can use both - the use of carbon with Purigen® will extend the useful life of the Purigen®. However, there is some mystery as to how the product works. 2 totally different products, but purigen does do some of the things GAC does. You likely would have to dose phosphate. Thread starter pinda; Start date May 1, 2007; The friendliest place on the web for anyone with an interest in aquariums or fish keeping! 📖 - Video Description:Difference between activated carbon and Seachem PurigenIn this video I will show you my opinion between activated carbon and Seachem P Nov 8, 2014 · Also, when using the Rox Carbon and GFO, is it safe to use it in conjunction with Purigen? And does Purigen bleach out coral? One last question about Purigen -- Is it similar in shape, size, and purpose of the Biomax filter media for the Aquaclear power filter? Can I use carbon and Purigen together? You can use both carbon and Purigen together in your tank. A 250 mL bottle of Matrix is a lot more affordable than a 250 mL bottle of Purigen. Just wondering what experience others have had using Purigen and whether you found it to be preferable to activated carbon? Purigen® is superior to carbon in removing organics and not having negative impacts, but it is also compatible with carbon. May 27, 2022 · If you add Seachem purigen in the recommended amount of water, it should start working after a few hours of placing. Renew works like Matrix Carbon but is less aggressive. Great for targeted removal of waste and color impurities from the water, but is not as aggressive as Purigen®. SPS like very clean water. Purigen does a better job of removing naturally occurring aquarium chemicals and tannins. Start new topic; Recommended Posts. Carbon or GAC(granular activated carbon) removes toxins and tannins from the water. Jul 2, 2022 · Both activated carbon and purigen have unique benefits and can be used together to achieve crystal clear water and maintain a healthy environment in the aqua Feb 14, 2020 · Purigen is a synthetic polymer resin that helps in reduction of nitrates. Member. Apart from keeping the DOCs, phosphates, and silicates levels in check, it also polishes water quality by removing the water’s foul odors. API Stress Coat is not compatible with Purigen. . This has been covered in multiple threads, I know because I researched them all before putting in my Purigen with my Carbon. The biggest difference between Purigen and carbon, is that if you do not change carbon often, it will release all of the toxins that it filtered back into the tank. The main purpose of Seachem Purigen is to purify the water column by removing waste that would normally break down into ammonia, nitrites, and nitrates. Amy Posted June 11, 2014. Oct 1, 2022 · Purigen will eliminate nitrogenous waste while removing discolorations from the water to make it clearer. Teebo Community Member View Badges. Use phosguard or GFO and if you use enough, it will remove the Jul 5, 2018 · This is basically a combination of activated carbon, Phosguard, and Purigen. 8), but both will work. After that, rinse Purigen thoroughly and it is now ready to use with your filter. Purigen? Thread starter Teebo; Start date Jan 18, 2018; Tagged users None Jump to Last Jan 18, 2018 #1 T. Chemipure functions pretty much exactly like purigen, but cannot be recharged. Apr 20, 2023 · Other good options are organic carbon dosing and growing macroalgae. Purigen works with reducing nitrogenous organic waste and polishes water. Jan 30, 2015 · As I stated earlier, use both. Or would I be better off skipping one (or both) and just loading up on bio-media for my top 3 trays? I'm planning on getting a SunSun HW-304B for my Oct 19, 2021 · Purigen and GAC will both bind organics, and may bind slightly different but overlapping types of organics. Carbon gets changed every two weeks and purigen every few months. Below some correlating factors to distinguish their differences. So there’s no benefit of having either one other than what you described? It doesn’t clean the water or have any beneficial properties? Jan 18, 2018 · Carbon not only removes toxins but polishes water. Also helps keep water clear. Feb 15, 2013 · I researched about purigen and carbon. Hypersorb is a resin like Purigen and regenerable, but Purigen has more of a focus than Hypersorb. You may or may not want to use a phosphate reducing media. Should I Use Purigen Or Carbon? The difference between Purigen and Carbon is minimal and it’s reduced to their economic and time-consuming aspects. I rinse my bag weekly and replace every 3 weeks. Carbon will help you clean up the water, and the purigen will clear the organic material out of water. F. According to what I've read, Purigen can be regenerated and used again, many times--which sounds economical. The only advantage Purigen has over Carbon that it can be recycle/recharge. But this question is mainly for shrimp only tank as it can only produce little ammonia, nitrate, etc Will it make a big different if I use Purigen over Carbon. Some people run Purigen and Chemipure together as well even though they do the same thing. jcmvl ridevb bhwmr xqisi lqjm icumb kxrwyfd wton rcok qxjkbmo

Carbon vs purigen. Oct 4, 2023 · Purigen.