Emd vs ge.
Jul 13, 2018 · Turbo performance GE (and Alco) vs.
Emd vs ge The EMD has A total of four lights for the whole cab which are all misplaced and hard to reach compared to numerous lights on the GE. Formerly a division of General Motors, EMD has been owned by Progress Rail since 2010. EMD post that he preferred the GE C60AC's over anything else, but I'm limiting this post to the 2004 new locomotives, C44AC vs. SD70MAC (and SD70ACe). x=en_USS U B S C R I B E T O T H I S C H A N N E L:https EMD's have A narrow 'ladder' to get on. GE 4746 views. Dec 23, 2015 · Up until 1982 EMD locomotive were built to high standards. EMD page here. I've heard the GE's are a bit more slippery than the EMDs. On General Electric models, this is usually shaped like a rectangular slab at the back of the long hood, supported by a slightly angled radiator grid below it. That is just the basics. Oct 15, 2009 · This is a thread created to host the opinions of all railfans on the GE vs. kf0cci EMD vs. EMD VS GE Locomotives, Which is Better?Locomotive Mashup#shorts #railfans #trains Feb 24, 2014 · I have wondered for a long time about the following, and just decided to ask. Most of the GE fuel tanks have a boxy shape with straight upper sides and the lower third angled in toward the flat bottom. [citation needed] Dec 8, 2008 · You should note that phases aren't actual EMD model designations, they're just categories that modelers and railfans use to group similar types of units. GE sold its locomotive business that year. Ask any older engineer and they will tell you EMD will get the job done better then any GE. Rahhhhhhhhh!!!! EMD vs GE Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, May 28, 2002 10:55 PM It appears that most of the people who chat on this site are very passionate in thier like for EMD's and thier dislike for GE's. These locomotives can be old or new it doesn;t matter EMD vs. Which do you prefer?C H E C K O U T T H E S E R E L A T E D V I D E O S: [T-167] Locomotives of Today's Class 1s: Norfolk Southernht It would be important to note that since 2019, GE Transportation is known as Webtec. Rahhhhhhhhh!!!! This was taken on September 7, 2019. Order Ascending; Order Descending; 1 2 3. Jul 3, 2008 · EMD took the competition in 1991 with GE very seriously for the AMD-103 specified by AMTRAK. EMD uses angled flairs when they use them. The problem was the SD50, which happened to be so bad, that was available around the same time as GE’s Dash, which was the best locomotive GE had ever built at that point. In fact, word was received on the last day of work before the Christmas shutdown in 1991 that GE had won the business, so the Director of Engineering held a last minute meeting to ream the troops before the holiday. GE 5346 views. Four of those ( EMDX 1206, 1208, 1209 and 1210) were sold to Canadian National Railway and renumbered to CN 8100–8103. EMD built about 1200 GP40s. EMD’s SD60 series, while much better than the SD50, still wasn’t as good as GE’s Dash 8 and Dash 9. Member since April 2003; 305,205 posts Posted We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Hope you enjoyed this clip on the sights and sounds of three different locomotive builders. E. The new GE ES44AC/DCs have 100 more horsepower than the new EMD SD70ACe/M-2 (4400 and 4300 HP respectively). The official Brookings Rail Watch webpage:http://trains. Think of an EMD as a sports car and a GE as a truck. Oct 22, 2019 · In 2020 the combined fleet was 51% GE to 46% EMD (the rest being from minor builders like NREC and Railpower, etc, and a few preserved but active steam locomotives). me/WorldCliqueEnt?locale. Does that mean the EMD is in effect “pushing” the GE’s until they reach 1,050? I would think that the GE would use less fuel than the EMD, but possibly the cost of turbo maintenance would cancel the savings. My personal view: I would not describe myself as pro-EMD or GE, I like both companies equally and I wish EMD had a greater market share for the sake of variety out on the tracks. GE built about 300 U30Bs. I've heard during that era the only reason GE sold any locomotives is because EMD couldn't produce enough to meet demand. " Sep 6, 2006 · Both have nearly identical specs. com. The 3 types of Diesel Locomotives used in Indian Jul 13, 2018 · Turbo performance GE (and Alco) vs. This video is a complitition of GE and EMD locomotives to help answer the question. GE's are wide stairs that you can climb on with your grip. I did meet a train last week with one of the new CSX Super Heavy C44AC's on it last week, so maybe I'll get one soon. Rahhhhhhhhh!!!! EMD vs. Re: EMD SD70AH vs GE ES44AH Question Author: MitchGDRMCo That was the change from MAC (Siemens) to ACe (Mitsubishi), the new system is a new inverter arrangement. A couple sets of DPU power (picture #1 - a pair of GE ES44AC's; picture #2 - a pair of EMD SD70ACe's) push hard on two different eastbound loaded coal trains fresh off of BNSF's Canyon Subdivision. These units, unlike previous SD70ACe's, have one inverter per axle on the trucks, rather than EMD's traditional one inverter per truck design. May 29, 2017 · GE not only ate EMD's lunch by giving the RR's an engine that could pull. EMD vs GE Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, May 28, 2002 10:55 PM It appears that most of the people who chat on this site are very passionate in thier like for EMD's and thier dislike for GE's. Feb 24, 2014 · in power or dynamic braking, each unit will do as it is designed, if you have a sd40-2, es4400,gp38 in a consist they will each respond to the leading locomotive signal thru the jumper cables, again as emd, ge alco, ect has designed or in the case of newer locomotives programed in the computers, you can run 50 year old locomotives with the Oct 12, 2024 · EMD vs GE; OGR Publishing, Inc. Jul 31, 2002 · Let's try a BIG PICTURE look at EMD vs GE. A fellow responded on the earlier GE vs. but i have yet to run a bad emd. The GE AC4400CW has higher tractive effort, horsepower, and dynamic braking ability than a EMD SD70MAC. Member since January 2005 EMD all the way. EMD or GE. This was the day I chased NS 192 between Columbia and Rock Hill. coborn35. I’m wondering if this Type of data resides anywhere - showing the split between EMD/GE sales per year - up to and including current year. They integrated the DPU operation and pretty much changed the industry in the process. I believe this is why EMD's have a higher pitched sound to them. They use to dominate their market with products that were the best enginered, most reliable, and cheapest to produce. From what other Jan 12, 2006 · The older U Boats had a shorter nose than the EMD. Here's a little guide that outlines the spotting features I use to tel From a look at the chart, GE seems to hold a lead over EMD in the basics. Rahhhhhhhhh!!!! Oct 6, 2023 · EMD VS GE Locomotives, Which is Better?Locomotive Mashup#shorts #railfans #trains This past September and October, I got the chance to photograph two very similar sized trains climbing the grade at Veazie, Maine. Membership Required We're sorry. Streamlined power cars and early experimental locomotives Jul 3, 2008 · EMD took the competition in 1991 with GE very seriously for the AMD-103 specified by AMTRAK. x=en_USS U B S C R I B E T O T H I S C H A N N E L:https Dec 12, 2020 · Nothing in the railfan community triggers debates, or strong feelings, as to who makes the better locomotive-GE or EMD. . Which is Best, GE, or EMD? Timestamps: 0:00 EMD Complitition 6:25 GE Com Discussing the different styles of EMD and GE locomotive radiators for identification purposes. In 2012, EMD also built four models known as the SD70ACe-P6. com/watch?v=1X7Earx EMD vs. Member since April 2003; 305,205 posts Posted Jul 20, 2021 · Diesel Engine Sounds | General Electric vs EMD (Electro-motive Diesel) vs ALCO (American Locomotive Company). Good Evening: I know this has probably been discussed before, but for engineers on this board: which is a better engine, the EMD SD70AC or the GE AC44? I think the specifications of the western roads for these units may be different than those of the eastern roads. Differences in prototypes often aren't intentional, but instead reflect parts or material availability, or supplier changes. S U P P O R T T H I S C H A N N E L: PAYPAL: https://paypal. Since most EMDs have 900 rpm max’s and GE has 1,050 rpm max’s, when going to notch 8 say on a mixed dpu consist of SD 70ACes and ES 44ACs, during that time where the GE is at 900 rpm, the EMD has maxed out. Anecdotally, my favorite rail Dec 12, 2020 · Nothing in the railfan community triggers debates, or strong feelings, as to who makes the better locomotive-GE or EMD. You Nov 6, 2021 · S U P P O R T T H I S C H A N N E L: PAYPAL: https://paypal. Link down below. 60 replies. 1. there are a few things i like about ge,very few. In the 80's every major GM division [5 auto, 2 truck, Detroit Deisel, EMD, etc. the railroad (ns) is buying 2 ge engines for the tidy sum of 3mil and just 1 emd is 3mil. GE 5965 views. Dec 28, 2022 · As new railfans we all had trouble telling the difference in the makes of locomotives. To expand on this explanation, railroads also looked at the TOTAL overall, LONG TERM cost differences on diesel units from EMD vs ALCO, and GE. EMD's apex of power came with the -2 line in 1972 for about a decade. ALCO built 16 C430s. most will say that a ge will pull when it gets slow on a hard pull. for swiching Oct 22, 2019 · Hi there, I recall seeing, a number of years back, a graph that showed the split of North American domestic locomotive sales. "EMD was here first," "GE's taste better. Electro-Motive Diesel (abbreviated EMD) is a brand of diesel-electric locomotives, locomotive products and diesel engines for the rail industry. This is your chance to vote in a poll and give your reasons why you support GE or EMD. The answer isn't always clear, cut an Apr 22, 2020 · The EMD units have smoothly rounded fuel tanks and many have air reservoirs tucked in along the tank top just below the running boards. You can find more on this subject on my GE vs. The evolution in Power is a somewhat gradual climb that ends in a sharp rise over the last 30 years. Anonymous. https://www. EMD and nomenclature Posted by YoHo1975 on Friday, July 13, 2018 12:33 AM So, I've been having a discussion with someone on another forum about whether or not the EMD 2 Cycle Turbo with overrunning clutch is a "true" turbo charger. youtube. Sep 30, 2021 · Yes and no. GE 6059 views. Sep 16, 2012 · EMD's turbochargers are mechanically driven through notch, 5 which allows them to load up much quicker than a GE. Both trains are snaking their way into the Guernsey, WY, train yard dur The following is a list of locomotives produced by the Electro-Motive Corporation (EMC), and its successors General Motors Electro-Motive Division (GM-EMD) and Electro-Motive Diesel (EMD). EMD's give full power at the first throttle setting while GE's notch up slower. GE. GEs always have noselights EMD vs GE Posted by Anonymous on Tuesday, May 28, 2002 10:55 PM It appears that most of the people who chat on this site are very passionate in thier like for EMD's and thier dislike for GE's. EMD and GE also use different trucks except in some cases, and on GE Dash units the rear has the rectangular flair on each side that EMD does not. GEs always have noselights Re: EMD ACe's vs GE ES44's Author: schmo I like the ES44AC's over the SD70ace's because the ES44's can pull a long train much better than a SD70ace locomotive and it takes a SD70ace a long time too start up and that's why the train crews hate them with a passion. Once they load up, a GE will pull right along with any other locomotive. ogaugerr. Not to be overlooked was the OVERHAUL cost of a GE unit from the 1960s through the 1980s, vs. My favorite modern locomotive is the SD70MAC, not a GE. the EMD unit. i find that a emd wont let you get slow. Most Engineers,and crews today prefer the Wide-Body cab now over older cab-types. EMD debate. , 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653 800-980-OGRR (6477) www. On September 25th, three E I work in a building next to a rail yard the trains move slow to fast , I have noticed that when a GE goes by the they are vibrations to the ground when an EMD goes by their isn't. GE, ALCO, and EMD's turbo and non-turbo. The AC4400CW has 1 inverter per axle, while the SD70MAC has only one inverter per truck. Just a few ground rules: Please refrain from "irrelevant" reasons for your support, I. Next the conductors office is merely A small card table on the EMD and A spacious desk on the GE. There is really nothing inherently wrong with GE locomotives. The Thanks for watching. Dec 12, 2024 · Let's look at three locomotives that are roughly comparable in terms of size, horsepower, number of axles, and importantly, the era when they were introduced (1965-66): EMD GP40, GE U30B, ALCO C430. Conrail conducted tests in the early 80's between EMD SD40-2's and GE C30-7's to evaluate their comparative fuel and maintenace costs, but I've never seen the results discussed anywhere. yes the differance is like fords chevy dodge soforth. EMD vs GE En los recientes meses se ha desatado una feroz disputa entre aficionados en distintos foros por decir que las mejores locomotoras de Norteamerica son General Electric y otros diciendo que lo mejor es Electro Motive Diesel. EMD vs. Feb 1, 2023 · The first thing to look at when spotting EMD vs GE diesels is the shape of the dynamic brake radiator and intake. GE, ALCO, and EMD's turbo and non May 8, 2001 · the reason ge are selling are due to the price. Posted by SD60MAC9500 on Wednesday, August 2, 2006 1:57 AM Here we go the ultimate flame board!!!!! Mark me down for EMD. ] was in trouble the same way. The answer isn't always clear, cut an EMD's have A narrow 'ladder' to get on. sgnqehubdudhacxzlqvyjnbjdzqtneeupdaqtrvkkeppmj