Commander rules committee discord. Or better guidance for it.

Commander rules committee discord length of RC/CAG membership, duties, succession etc. There’s a specific channel on the Commander RC Discord server dedicated to discussing the quarterly updates. '" He added that announcements of changes to the format will not align with the regularly scheduled Banned/Restricted updates seen by other formats. It should be the reverse. They'll be on the RC Discord server channel at 1130 to chat with you all. Dec 26, 2024 · The Commander Format Panel is a group of community members with the mandate to help Wizards of the Coast manage Commander. This website is not affiliated nor endorsed by Wizards of the Coast™. First the Link. We don't normally disclose who voted which way, but we are making an exception. Some people are ecstatic, others are furious, but if you engage with Magic on the Internet you know this is all anyone’s been talking about. The one thing I wish the rules committee could create is some way to assign power levels to decks. co/GZye6FbJNA. I didn't like how he talked about them and unsubbed. Here's the full announcement: https://t. Needless to say, there’s a lot to talk about. patreon. Bobby BFine, creator and tournament organizer over at Sanctuary PDH, Scarecrow aka Paul who is a member of the Pauper EDH Rules Committee, and my good friend Yami who is a tournament grinder and overall amazing cPDH player! Sep 25, 2024 · Commander Rules Committee decisions are rarely unanimous. Then all six of us descended on Magic 30 in Las Vegas. The format is now managed by Wizards of the Coast. This is a subreddit dedicated to playing the Commander format of Magic: The… They refuse to do anything because they don't want the backlash of banning a card and pushing its price down to $0, and because they're in the pocket of WOTC's financial interests and they have literal WOTC employees infiltrating the organization, like Scott Larabee on the Rules Committee. Players start with 25 life and 21 commander damage is lethal. PlayEDH is most useful for deck-checks and finding games where opponents' power levels are near what you expect. Administrative. 89K subscribers in the CompetitiveEDH community. Oct 22, 2024 · Olivia is an expert at keeping the fun and lighthearted nature of Commander firmly in mind while also switching on a dime to have serious conversations about the format's future and what it needs. Idiotic. First Printed: 1993-AUG-05 Banned: — Ancestral Recall was originally banned for poor optics, rather than power level. Here, I ponder over the current perception of the RC. We embraced the opportunity to get out into the crowd and not just play, but talk Commander with a fairly Sep 30, 2024 · As a result of the threats last week against RC members, it has become impossible for us to continue operating as an independent entity. This time I was joined by some of the bigger names in the community, including Mr. The CAG is only allowed to participate in discussions and make recommendations. Note that the Rules Committee is different from the Commander Advisory Group, which these two people were previously on. by N e m e s i s. Its organization has changed over the years. For example, in addition to (or instead of) the "banned list We're back with the monthly pauper pod, which streamed live at the very end of April. Nov 25, 2024 · Things went well for Duel Commander. We embraced the opportunity to get out into the crowd and not just play, but talk Commander with a fairly Mar 16, 2023 · The remainder of the document (and most dense part) concerns the operations put forth in support of the philosophy. 30, 2024, 2:21 p. I long for a more nuanced set of rules for casual commander like "you can have X as your commander, but you may not include Y in your deck" or "you may not play Z as your commander", while competitive commander can get it's own stricter bans. Thank you for being our community's voice. « Reply #15 on: September 08, 2024, 11:46:51 pm » I'm not against tutors exactly, I just don't see the point of permitting them but not Wishes. — Jim Lapage (@JimTSF) September 24, 2024 Commander Rules Committee Plans For 2022 and you should hop on the discord, in which it was pointed that it was totally a group choice and not something seriously Seems unlikely to have any major effect on the format, but I think having a diversity of voices on the rules committee is generally positive. There’s a great community over on the Commander RC Discord server, just waiting for you to come join us. Players choose a legendary creature as the commander for their deck. We’ve Jul 29, 2024 · We know that silver-bordered cards are often contentious (and often with good reason), but we want to put the collective expertise of the Commander Advisory Group and Rules Committee to work in classifying the cards that are generally fine, the cards that can be fine with a little work, and the cards that people should generally steer clear of There are a few things I can't stand about the RC & CAG: The RC/CAG doesn't have a transperant structure and code of conduct. gg/x5Q5PVg Jul 29, 2024 · We know that silver-bordered cards are often contentious (and often with good reason), but we want to put the collective expertise of the Commander Advisory Group and Rules Committee to work in classifying the cards that are generally fine, the cards that can be fine with a little work, and the cards that people should generally steer clear of The Commander Rules Committee (or RC) is an independent group of Commander fans and players who maintain the rules and an official banned list for the Magic: The Gathering Commander format at MTGCommander. Per the rules it could not be played as a commander. Success: The RC Discord Server. For example, unlike Pauper, Commander already had several community groups that ran it: the Commander Rules Committee and the Commander Advisory Group (CAG). Sep 30, 2024 · In this video, Jake and Joel are talking about the new Magic: the Gathering news that took place on September 30, 2024. The Commander RC’s official announcement is as follows: The Commander Rules Committee stated that they were unable to continue operating independently due to the backlash received from the ban announcement. This is after at least one member of the complimentary Commander Advisory Group quit due to harassment. To us, as many changes as usual were discussed, but overall the metagame seems stable, Rules. While there are many similarities, there are some differences, too. While it’s plenty powerful, it’s the effect on perceived barrier-to-entry that really posed a problem because casual players watching Commander games in passing could reasonably assume that they needed hundreds (now thousands) of dollars in Power-9 mana as table stakes The official mtg commander rules committee discord just locked the server to read only until further notice. Mtg. It's a cool card but giving it to the Commander Rules Committee is weird. Needless to say, this can be a complicated thing to navigate; but have no fear, this episode we’re going over those unofficial rules and expectations of the format. Verhey explained that the success and ongoing community involvement with the Pauper Format Panel inspired WotC to build the Commander variant after Sep 30, 2024 · As a result of the threats last week against RC members, it has become impossible for us to continue operating as an independent entity. The "clarification" is a straight up rules change targeted at EDH. Olivia pushed back against yesterday's change. He dabbles in competitive play as a commentator for (and on rare occasions, player in) PDH tournaments, but mostly he enjoys assembling inefficient engines and executing goofy play patterns in casual PDH games with Pals. This system is still being tweaked behind the curtains, but the Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. Given that, we have asked WotC to assume responsibility for Commander and they will be making decisions and announcements going forward. Reply Oct 1, 2024 · Wizards of the Coast has announced it will manage Magic: The Gathering‘s Commander format from now on, taking the reins from the third-party Commander Rules Committee. ” Sep 30, 2024 · tl;dr the Rules Committee, which was previously five community members who would perform any changes to Commander rules and its banlist, is handing control over to the actual Wizards design team. The RC receives input from the Commander Advisory Group (the CAG), a team of community leaders with diverse opinions and extensive contacts, who represent a breadth of perspectives on the format May 20, 2024 · PDH Rules Committee members have also had a number of opportunities to talk directly with governing members of larger formats, like the Pauper Format Panel, Commander Rules Committee, and Commander Advisory Group; through podcasts, discord messages, and in person at conventions. net. This structure has thrived, until now. Right now, we're within a stable structure, after lots of changes. tv/Magic. I know going in that we had some rather ambitious things in mind. That would give the banlist a lot clearer purpose and reach than it does right now. None of us are above criticism but if you hate the bans, she was your voice in the room. When working with her as a Commander Rules Committee member, she always brought great, honest insight, and I know that's going to continue with the CFP. The rules for Commander are set by the Commander Rules Committee (“the RC” or “CRC”) and updated approximately every 3 months, if needed. Oct 1, 2024 · The Magic: The Gathering community's been in turmoil lately, but first, some much-needed context for the uninitiated among you: The Commander Rules committee is a volunteer group of MTG players Sep 26, 2024 · This week’s ban announcement – removing Dockside Extortionist, Jeweled Lotus, Mana Crypt, and Nadu from the format – took the Commander community by storm. “Casual” commander is opt in. A card’s color identity is its color plus the color of any mana symbols in the card’s rules text . With this change came the announcement of a new “bracket system” that’ll be used to govern the power level of Commander decks. The only difference between this and wotc tacking on a "This can be your commander" is they are doing it a way that doesn't directly reference EDH. [1][2][3] Oct 1, 2024 · Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. — Commander Rules Committee (@mtgcommander) September 30, 2024 Oct 22, 2024 · One significant change from the original Rules Committee is that these aren't volunteers, all members of the new Commander Format Panel will be paid, according to principal designer Gavin Verhey. Commander (EDH) forum Posted on Sept. Edit: I meant rules committee not commander advisory board. The intent is Sep 30, 2024 · Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. In Commander: Awful, 3-mana rock that's more vulnerable, slower, and eventually becomes an unreliable source of mana. CAG Members Sep 30, 2024 · Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. cardsrealm. This shift in power brings the 13-year era of community management to an end. I know that they have an incredibly complicated problem to address with this, and there are a lot of risks involved. Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. Here you'll find all the material you need about Duel Commander, a community-driven game based on Magic The Gathering™: rules, currently banned and restricted cards, a FAQ, the history of our game, how we work and who we are, a d irectory of venues and people who get involved, and a dedicated place to ask us anything. Sep 25, 2024 · The Commander Rules committee has just announced shocking new bannings for Commander, shaking up the format and removing some of the most played cards from the format. — Commander Rules Committee (@mtgcommander) September 30, 2024 Dec 31, 2021 · Expansion on the Philosophy Document will likely come as a series of essays from RC and CAG members, or potentially some of the deep thinkers among the player base. Here’s how this card type interacts with the rules of Commander! Commander Tax Refer to Rule 6: Commanders begin the game in the Command Zone. In the same spirit,I want to close out this year by reviewing those goals and assessing how we did in meeting them. Gist is, the RC is giving management of the Commander format to the game design team of WotC. The commander advisory committee is an invited group of Commander community leaders who use their breadth of perspectives on the format to assist the Rules Committee. '" In a glance, Duel Commander rules used to derive from Commander rules which originate from EDH rules and derive from general MTG rules. Banned: Dockside Extortionist; Nadu, Winged Wisdom; Mana Crypt; Jeweled Lotus The commander advisory board are regular ppl, who love the game and volunteer. Please note we Nov 3, 2022 · Every time a quarterly update has no changes to the Commander Banned List, there’s a fraction of the population who will inevitably say, “The Rules Committee does nothing!” This happens mostly because they’re used to other formats (especially non-Eternal ones) being more dynamic, living on a less stable foundation. Dave (known unprofessionally as Alkadron on Discord and Reddit) has been playing magic since 1995, and PDH since 2013. PlayEDH is just the match-making discord server. For example, consider the below comments from the Commander Rules Committee Discord server: About this external resources directory Here is a list of all resources known and/or which requested to be listed here. However, in unsanctioned casual games in general, the players in the game can agree on which cards are legal and which are banned in a Commander variant game, either generally or as a commander. Here are our thoughts. Sep 30, 2024 · We have opened a new Discord channel on the official Magic Discord (in the #Commander_News channel) and will also have a WeeklyMTG stream talking about this tomorrow, October 1, at 10 a. Even though these Sep 23, 2024 · The Commander Rules Committee formerly maintained the rules and the ban list for the Magic: The Gathering Commander format. . Sep 30, 2024 · A week ago, the independent Rules Committee for Magic: The Gathering Commander, the collectible card game’s most popular format in recent years, announced a surprise ban of three of its most Sep 16, 2024 · From 2014 to 2016, the Duel Commander Committee has created a structured internal organization, with 4 different roles, designed to better adapt to its needs. Sep 30, 2024 · Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. If you enjoy this video, click like and subscribe. It is the end of the Commander Rules Committee, which means the future of MTG's favorite format, Commander, is uncertain. We haven’t had any bans in a while and I think commander is as healthy as ever. PT on Twitch. The Commander's Quarters is your Magic the Gathering source that helps you Command Your Budget! Today Eddie joins Mitch to talk about The Rules Committee Rul Sep 30, 2024 · The dissolution of Commander's Rules Committee comes after a wave of controversial card bans last week. The Commander Rules Committee (or RC) was an independent group of Commander fans and players who maintained the rules and an official banned list for the Magic: The Gathering Commander format at MTGCommander. "I could imagine a world where we go to quarterly updates, something the Rules Committee had done, but all that is still 'TBD. Sep 30, 2024 · As a response to this change of command, members of the Commander RC had a few things to say: According to the body of this tweet, Jim Lapage of the Rules Committee explains that he sees Commander as growing beyond the scope of the five members of its governing body. As always, we have a channel on the Commander RC Discord server dedicated to a good-faith discussion on format philosophy. with Wizards already establishing a Discord community for Commander players to discuss Oct 7, 2020 · Today we are interviewing Paul or Scarecrow1779, one of the Pauper Commander Committee members to better understand this format. The A variety of other house rules and whether making them official would benefit the format. The RC Discord server has been one of the unmitigated successes of the last year. Before reading the rules below, please read the philosophy of commander; simply following the rules is not sufficient to ensure a good play experience. No Changes. Deck Construction Rules. Working to help them design a better game for the format’s fans is the kind of place we want to be. 1a As opposed to common multiplayer formats like Commander (as promoted by the Commander community and Wizards of t he Coast's Commander), and as stated in its name, Duel Commander is made f or 1 versus 1, individual player games (referred as “two-player games” in the Magic The Gathering™ Comprehensive Rules at section 100. Copying this site's contents while mentioning the original source is authorized on the condition that it remains up to date. Dec 19, 2024 · The Commander format’s in a bit of a transitional period right now, having shifted from the loving embrace of the Commander Rules Committee to the cold corporate clutches of Wizards of the Coast. “We’ve been talking about these bans with each other, with Wizards (so they can do their own communications and align bans with MTGO) for a Sep 26, 2024 · Support the show and become a Patron! Be a part of our community, receive awesome rewards, and more! https://www. Oct 11, 2024 · The rules of EDH/Commander only existed to provide a basic set of rules to get everyone started on the same page, the Commander Rules Committee was never going to knock your door down and enforce Oct 22, 2024 · I feel like it's worked out well, and it's the base that we wanted to model Commander's community group after. There has been a metric tonne of discussion about the bans. In a new blog post, the company has confirmed this news is related to recent Commander card bans which led to a major storm of opinions online, many of which were “harmful or malicious. Rules committee makes banlist, commander advisory board, well, advises. Sep 30, 2024 · The Commander format has been a fan-managed format since its inception, with the Rules Committee at the helm for nearly 20 years. High power commander is opt out. Olivia Gobert-Hicks and Jim LaPage join Scott Larabee, Toby Elliot, Gavin Duggan, and Sheldon Menery at the RC expands to six members. The admin for the official Commander Discord server posted a statement that included this Braids, Cabal Minion Originally banned (as a commander: June 2009 Fully banned: September 2014 Unbanned: never The original announcement where she was banned as a commander cites two issues with Braids: first that getting her out early can be a hard lock to break out of if you aren't prepared for it, and second that the Rules Committee didn't want games devolve into being about a single card Sep 30, 2024 · Rules Committee Gives Up Managing Commander. I'm sure Mitch got that part right in his video. As always, thanks for watching. e. No changes* The asterisk on Administrative Changes is a reminder that we added two folks, Olivia Gobert-Hicks and Jim Lapage, to the Rules Committee. Per Wizards’ announcement introducing the Commander Format Panel, it functions similarly to the Pauper Format Panel, who “work together to monitor the health of [the format], suggest changes, and discuss things like ban updates. This open space allows for a wide variety of voices to be heard by other members where constructive commentary is highly encouraged. Oct 2, 2024 · Sheldon founded the Commander Rules Committee (RC) to help guide the format down these hopeful paths. com/commandzone ——– Show Notes: Jul 7, 2020 · In many ways, our discussions mirror the ones in the Commander community at large (including the arguments for and against), but we are in no way beholden to the philosophies held by the Commander Rules Committee. Mar 28, 2024 · On top of all that, Commander has a whole set of UNWRITTEN rules that can be a little less cut-and-dry. Oct 3, 2024 · The Commander Rules Committee has decided to officially hand over control of the format to Wizards of the Coast. Some of our favourite Commander-related sites around the internet: The Commander Staple is a Discord server focused on creating a positive and inviting space for community members to gather, collaborate, and share with each other. I. A week ago, the independent Rules Committee for Magic: The Gathering Commander, the collectible card game’s most popular format in recent years, announced a surprise ban of three of its most Another quarterly update, another nothing-burger. m. Today, we’re happy to announce that these modifications have been made to the banlist page. The issue is that, according to a Discord message from Jim Lapage, a member of the Commander Rules Committee, the recent bans were actually in the works while these sets were being promoted and sold. It discusses the baseline rules and how we maintain them, the greater functions and operations of the RC and Commander Advisory Group (CAG), communication with Wizards of the Coast (WotC), a detailed section on community outreach, and other specifics of operation, to include a Sep 30, 2024 · Unfortunately, the task of managing Commander has far outgrown the scope and safety of being attached to any five people. net Sep 12, 2022 · We are pleased to announce that @goberthicks and @JimTSF have joined the Commander RC. Mar 28, 2021 · All text contents are property of the Duel Commander Rules Committee. Notably, they're stating that they're reexamining the banlist, though won't be banning anything in the near future. . The Commander Advisory Committee. So today, in partnership with members of the existing Rules Committee, we are announcing that the Rules Committee is giving management of the Commander format to the game design team of Wizards of the Coast. Aug 12, 2020 · All text contents are property of the Duel Commander Rules Committee. There is an active dialogue currently ongoing in the Commander Rules Committee Discord server: https://discord. | 2653 members Hello, dear Duel Commander players from around the world, This is just a summed up note regarding the Duel Commander Rules Committee itself. We look forward to you stopping on by and discussing it, as well as a host of other topics, with now more than 7,000 friends. It's Commander singleton, same as Commander rules, but only played in 1 vs 1 (duel) games, with a starting life total of 20 life, as in all sanctionned duel formats, has no commander damage rule anymore, is Oct 22, 2024 · After a series of controversial decisions led to the mass resignation of Magic: The Gathering’s Commander Rules Committee, Wizards of the Coast has named the new body that will replace it. Oct 1, 2024 · "Stability is a key part of what makes Commander 'Commander. While a commander is in the command zone, it may be cast, subject to the normal timing restrictions for casting creatures. A good example of divergence is our usage of both “Banned as Commander” and “Banned as Companion” lists. There are sometimes a fair number of dots to connect between the Philosophy Document and the Banned List — especially since the Banned List isn’t the only major tool we use in sculpting the Sep 26, 2024 · Magic: The Gathering’s Commander (EDH) community has voiced significant concerns over the recent banning of key cards, leading to the creation of two petitions: one demanding the removal of the Commander Rules Committee (CRC) and another seeking to reverse the bans. Nov 25, 2024 · 🖖 This is our main website to help everyone find our essential resources. 205. Those resources are NOT linked to the Duel Commander Rules Committee. This month saw the world record for a single, continunous tournament attendance beaten by RelicTCG, with an outstanding 913 players registered at the start of the tournament. Either they are sick of seeing Jan 17, 2022 · I’ve had conversations with some of the team and I’m pleased with how they’re coming to think about Commander. This is something we will not tolerate. R. Sep 30, 2024 · Below and over the next few days and weeks, we will be discussing quite a bit about Commander, starting with the most pressing: Over the past week, the conversation has escalated, culminating with unacceptable personal threats to the safety of members of the Commander Rules Committee. We need real leadership for the format. This is why they have allowed Wizards of the Coast to step in and take command Between now and then, we look forward to enjoying what new things come to us in Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur’s Gate and Warhammer 40,000 Commander. Magic: the The Commander variant (under C. 1a). We decided it is now the time for us to change how we are structured, once again. Why do I need to have a long ass conversation to play lower powered commander but any spikey style commander is just sit down and play. It is not a characteristic defining ability because it has conditions. We do not guaranttee what you will find there, only a limited curation of links as found below. It was my mistake. Oct 1, 2024 · Verhey, a Principal Game Designer and lead of the Commander Design Team, and Forsythe, the Vice President of Game Design and Creative, spent the hour fielding questions from social media, the Twitch chat, and the new Discord channel from the official Magic Discord. Sep 24, 2024 · Here are some Commander player comments from X (formerly Twitter): Not only are we seeing responses similar to the poll results on X in reaction to the ban, but similar reactions are also unfolding in other forums. The committee has grown from one person, a long time ago, to (round) 20 today. See full list on mtgcommander. After much consideration and debate, the PDC RC set their rules as follows: The commander and rarity rules are the same as PDH (only creatures with an uncommon printing). 903) has its own deckbuilding rules that apply regardless of which cards are legal in a particular game. They use Spelltable to facilitate the games. Or better guidance for it. Login. 38 votes, 65 comments. The Rules Committee gets to actually vote on decisions and have much more control over the shape of the format. Wilds of Eldraine brings with it two Adventure commanders. Nov 4, 2022 · Rules. This server is the official Duel Commander server, maintained by the Duel Commander Rules Committee. Dec 29, 2022 · I closed out last year by discussing the Commander Rules Committee’s (RC) goals for 2022. From a rules standpoint, there would just need some language to clear up a few things that most people already assume about wishboards, but need to be explicitly stated; that the cards need to conform to the color identity of your commander, that the highlander rule still applies (cards in your maindeck can't be in your wishboard and vice versa Sep 9, 2024 · Re: So say you're on the Commander Rules Committee. " Jan 27, 2024 · Previously, the best way to research these topics was to dig through our old banlist announcements, or read articles written by Sheldon or the other members of the Rules Committee. Rules. We embraced the opportunity to get out into the crowd and not just play, but talk Commander with a fairly Nov 13, 2024 · Most cEDH Discord servers have some common elements: decklist channels for folks looking for feedback on their lists, as well as pinned lists of top-performing players piloting the Commander in question, and channels for game discussion, mulligans, and threads for discussing potentially new cards, and techs for the base deck. They highlight potential format improvements, discuss impact of proposed changes, and help the RC stay in touch with the community. wrznm peev orgid jshx ftmo kjucao yyv ydfm diff ymf